
Eli Manning is taking the New York Giants back to the Superbowl this year, cementing himself firmly in my personal top three Manning's. His solid year included only 16 interceptions and 6 fumbles, a stark contrast from his typical ratio of 1 completion::1 turnover.
Yes, Eli has won back my confidence and is now easily amongst my top all-time Mannings. That group of course includes father, Archie Manning, his wife Olivia and kids Cooper, Peyton and lil' Eli.
After a woeful 2010, I had Eli ranked near the bottom of the barrel, but with a win last night over the San Francisco 49ers, I can now honestly say that he has vaulted into the top three in both power rank and overall.
Each Manning has a solid list of pros, cons, tangibles and intangibles that I consider. The fact that Eli has a working neck means he's above Peyton in the power rankings, but it's the overall rank that really matters, so let's take a closer look:
Archie Maninng-Three-year started for Ole Miss
-Still holds the SEC record for all-purpose yards in a game with 540
-1971 NFL draft second-overall pick
-Ten seasons in the NFL, two pro bowls
Peyton Manning-1998 NFL draft 1st overall pick
-Four MVP awards, most in NFL history
-11 time Pro Bowl selection, Superbowl XLI winner, MVP
-Make hilarious advertisements with fake mustaches
Olivia Manning-Senior year homecoming queen
-Member of Women of the Storm, Hurricane Katrina charity group with badass name
-Delta Gamma alumnus
-Three-time delivery room MVP '74, '76, '81
Cooper Manning-All-State Wide Receiver and blue chip recruit, playing career ended by spinal stenosis
-Convinced Peyton to wear brown paper bag on his head to a Saints game during their father's playing days
-Partner at an energy investment firm in New Orleans
-Is still filthy rich
Eli Manning
-2004 NFL draft 1st overall pick
-Superbowl XLII winner and MVP
-two-time Pro Bowl selection
-Regularly captured on film wasted out of his gourd, with sharpie on face
Superbowl XLVI will be a rematch between Eli and his arch nemesis, Tom Brady. It will be a rematch of Superbowl XLII in which the Giants defeated the New England Patriots 17-14. New York was a major underdog then, becoming the first team to win the Superbowl after coming from the NFC wildcard spot to defeat the previously undefeated Patriots.
This time around, New York will be underdogs once more. Brady will be vying to tie Terry Bradshaw (Pittsburgh Steelers) for most Superbowl victories. We'll find out in two weeks if Brady is going to turn in a winning performance. In the tranquil indoors of Lucas Oil Stadium in Indianapolis, my thoughts are that Brady will be tough to overcome. So it's up to the youngest Manning to pull of another stunner, can he do it?